Heresy, Inquisition, Jihad, Fatwa and the Hare Krsnas

Jul 19 2010 - Krishna Talk 110

What do heresy, the Inquisition, jihad and fatwa have in common with some Hare Krsnas?


If you have done your homework and watched a few documentaries then you will know that back in the Middle Ages heresy was no laughing matter. The Inquisition (between 1184 CE and the 1800's) charged hundreds of thousands of innocent people with heresy and condemned them to death by being burnt at the stake. Similarly, the words 'jihad' and 'fatwa' conjure up images of Iraq and Afghanistan where innocent people are put to death by being decapitated and thousands of men, women and children suffer great tribulation under the draconian rule of fanatical clerics and their henchmen.

But the Hare Krsnas — we’re different, aren’t we?

Or are we?

Well, I would say that overall, most Hare Krsnas are different. But unfortunately a mentality similar to the Inquisition and the jihadists lives on in the minds of some so-called Hare Krsnas who are more like those suffering from NPD [Narcissistic Personality Disorder] than inspired representatives of Krsna. Sadly, this unpleasant truth became evident when leading figures in the Hare Krsna Movement conspired and ordered the death of one of their own members in 1986. The victim was an outspoken critic of leaders in the movement. His name was Sulocana – all but forgotten now…‘the one whose name should not be uttered’.

The murder made headline news in Los Angeles in the summer of ‘86 and sent a shock wave around the movement. Leaders, GBCs, gurus and sannyasis scrambled to make sure they were not implicated until justice finally found its mark and the hit man and several of those involved in the murder went to prison. Twenty-four years later all are free and back on the streets, chanting on their beads…all except for one – the man who pulled the trigger, Thomas Drescher. He is still doing his morning sadhana behind bars.

If you have read the horrifying book, Monkey on a Stick then you will know that things were very bad in the Hare Krsna Movement during that era and that several murders (solved and unsolved) took place at New Vrndavana and in other parts of the world during those years — all within the movement. These murders had one thing in common — the victims were outspoken and rebellious and they crossed their leaders.

During the Dark Ages in Europe, if one crossed the Church or voiced any type of dissent it was as good as signing one’s own death warrant. There are similarities between the Church and the Hare Krsnas, though things are not as severe now as they were then. To criticize leadership in the Hare Krsna Movement has always been the shortcut to being ostracized, ridiculed, isolated, even excommunicated — everything just short of being hung, drawn and quartered. You know… “Give the dog a bad name, then shoot him!”

But there is another development in the air and that is to single out those who have a different understanding of the philosophy of Krsna consciousness – to condemn them as offenders and demonize them by any means. This has been going on for years. It is not surprising that in many cases, the dissenters that throw off the yoke of ‘Ultimate Authority’ are often found to have the correct philosophy. “God so much loves the little man, the meek, the speaker of truth.”

But that matters little in the halls of religious imperialism and papal bureaucracy where those suffering from narcissistic behavioral patterns may even pass as the infallible acarya.

But hey! What’s new? In the time of Srila Bhaktisiddhanta, his life was threatened several times due to his outspoken presentation of the truth. He spoke out boldly against those who misrepresented the philosophy of Krsna consciousness even if it put his life in danger. And today, threats of violence and even murders take place amongst members of the same mission/sampradaya! I think I know this as well as anyone. I have always been an outspoken preacher and that tendency has brought me threats of death and violence on more than one occasion.

The Hare Krsna Movement (with all its different missions and branches) is very big and has many, many members around the world. But it is miserably weak and undernourished when it comes to proper conception/ proper spiritual philosophy.

My last Krsna Talk article, Sriya Suka made me quite aware of this once again. After the article was released, it wasn't long before I received a flurry of emails denouncing me as a maha-aparadhi (great offender), as ‘envious’ and many things worse than that. In these emails I was thoroughly condemned and warned to “prepare to be devastated”! What ‘devastated’ was supposed to mean, I don’t know for sure. I assume it meant that soon, Lord Krsna would smite me down for my evil deed of using my brain and researching sastra – and all because my article disagreed with the view of a popular guru of our times who claims that Sukadeva Gosvami was the pet parrot of Srimati Radharani.

I had to pinch myself. Was this for real? Was I being condemned, as in a heresy trial four hundred years ago? Was I next in line to be burnt at the stake? My accusers would have happily settled to see my neck in a noose, but fortunately for me emails can’t kill.

Disagree with the Church in medieval times and you were a dead man. Disagree with a Muslim cleric and a fatwa for your assassination may be issued. Disagree with a Hare Krsna guru who has the most disciples and you find yourself in a world of excrement – criticized, ostracized, ridiculed, isolated, condemned, excommunicated or even dead, if you don’t watch your back.

I know for a fact that mine is no isolated incident. Many devotees have been, and continue to be, dealt with in the same way if they dare think for themselves – what to speak of disagree with the ‘All-knowing, omniscient guru’. This however is not a good sign for a spiritual movement.

Unless the Hare Krsnas can learn to discuss philosophical points of view without fearing that their guru is under attack, or that they have to sacrifice life and limb to protect the guru from being questioned — then you can expect the worse for the future of the Hare Krsna Movement.

If that is the case, then the Hare Krsna Movement will surely deteriorate (as other movements before it) into becoming nothing more than a mundane cult of dogmatic principles with an elite clergy vying for wealth, fame and followers, but devoid of any true spiritual knowledge or inner experience of Krsna.

The solution? Abandon the thinking that your guru is the only guru and that anyone who differs from you or your guru is automatically a maha-aparadhi or a demon. This is the mentality that consumed Iskcon in the 1980’s and caused their demise. This same mentality is now present in some groups of Hare Krsnas that originally left Iskcon to make a fresh start, but who have ended up creating a community of Hare Krsnas with the same woes! A step in the right direction at this point would be for Hare Krsnas to start learning how to think and to question and not to be afraid of the truth. Krsna lives in the truth, so why settle for anything less?